A framework for analysing the evolution of the IS field - can IS become a stable discipline?

There is much concern among IS researchers due to the failure to establish adequate conceptual and theoretical foundations, and also the lack of clear definitions of concepts and terminology in the IS field. This paper considers why this is the case, and puts forward a framework which has been developed to analyse the emergence of the IS field, its relationship with associated disciplines, and the problems it currently faces. These problems are of a fundamental nature and include the field's identity crisis and epistemological problems; the failure to erect barriers to entry; the reference discipline problem; and the trend towards increased divergence rather than harmony and convergence in the field. Urgent research is needed to lay the foundation of a model for progress in the IS field which will support the evolution of the field towards control and harmony. This need is now stronger than ever at a time when the status of IS comes under attack in academic circles and the field seems to be under pressure to establish a stronger identity and solve fundamental methodological problems.