posted on 2022-09-12, 10:49authored byElaine M. Smith
As the effects of the ‘refugee crisis’ continue to diversify society, children of refugee
backgrounds emerge as a vulnerable minority group with increasing presence in Irish schools.
Demographic changes can give rise to intergroup tensions and increase prejudices. The
school setting provides a fertile ground to actively foster inclusive attitudes among the
emerging generations. Across three studies, this thesis develops and tests a field intervention
integrating normative influence and imagined intergroup contact with the aim to reduce
children’s anti-refugee bias in schools.
The first study (N = 266) compares children’s normative influences from different
ingroups to determine their relative importance for children’s anti-refugee bias. Perceived
support for inter-ethnic contact from children’s family and religious ingroups were revealed
to significantly predict anti-refugee bias above the contributions of other ingroup norms.
The second study (N = 545) experimentally tests a novel variant of imagined contact
intervention – norm-framed imagined contact. Compared to a control scene, children who
imagined contact framed in contexts of supportive family, class-peer and religious ingroup
norms had significantly lower anti-refugee bias.
The final study (N = 269) examines the longevity of the effects of norm-framed
imagined contact as a field intervention across ten classes. Anti-refugee bias was measured
before and two-weeks after a series of four imagined contact activities conducted over four
weeks. Though the long-term efficacy of norm-framed imagined contact was minimal,
children in the class-peer norm-framed condition showed significantly reduced bias on one
outcome compared to children in the standard imagined contact condition. Findings from this
study and the second study above reveal the particular importance of class peer contexts in
relation to children’s anti-refugee bias.
These studies collectively advance our understanding of the role of social norms for
children’s intergroup bias by first illustrating that normative influences can derive from
multiple sources, including religious ingroups, as well as family and peers. This research also
demonstrates the power of particular normative climates to enhance prejudice-reduction
interventions based on imagined contact. Lastly, it sheds light on the utility of norm-framed
imagined contact as a teacher-led, class-based activity to address bias against refugees, an
emerging vulnerable group in Irish society.